Paines Creek is Brewster's easternmost beach. This area is creek fed on one side, and its water is comfortably warm (65-70 degrees) during the summer. The topography here is somewhat rockier than other town beaches like Breakwater. A small lot offers limited parking and portable toilets are present for summer convenience. However, lifeguards are not on duty here. Kates Ice Cream is located a short distance (about ¼ mile) down the road, providing all kinds of fried/grilled fare. Additionally, the ice cream truck visits Paine's Creek daily in-season.