July 26, 2010 - There will be no federal climate change legislation this year. Last week Senate Democratic Majority Leader Harry Reid said that the votes were not there. Republicans are unanimously opposed and some Democrats, those who find the interests of their constituents aligned with carbon extraction and usage industries (auto, coal, oil), are opposed as well. This has taken place in the midst of a heat wave and compelling evidence, incontrovertible in the minds of most scientists, that global warming is a reality.
Do all conservatrves think global warming is a hoax? Not at all. Then why do all of them now oppose taking action on it? In today's NY Times conservative columnist Ross Douthat provides an explanation. Douthat does not deny global warming. He thinks it's as real as Al Gore does. He differs on what to do about it. Conservatives remember the 1970's he explains. Back then the big worry was population growth:
The Seventies were a great decade for apocalyptic enthusiasms, and none was more potent than the fear that human population growth had outstripped the earth’s carrying capacity. According to a chorus of credentialed alarmists, the world was entering an age of sweeping famines, crippling energy shortages, and looming civilizational collapse.
It was not lost on conservatives that this analysis led inexorably to left-wing policy prescriptions — a government-run energy sector at home, and population control for the teeming masses overseas.
Those fears were not realized and many conservatives believe that today's global warming fears will prove to be similarly wrong. Douthat thinks otherwise:
History, however, rarely repeats itself exactly — and conservatives who treat global warming as just another scare story are almost certainly mistaken.With that said, Douthat then writes that a proper response for the time being may be to do nothing. Regulating carbon emissions on a global scale is impossible so we might as well just muddle through. Here's Douthat's op-ed piece.









